Alder, ash and mahogany guitar bodies side by side

Guitar Body Wood Guide: Alder, Ash, Mahogany and More

Guide Wood by wood Ash vs alder

Guitar Body Wood Guide: Alder, Ash, Mahogany and More

Guitar body wood decides three things you notice every day: how heavy the guitar is, how it looks under the finish and, to a smaller degree, how it sounds. This guide compares the woods used for solid body electric guitars, settles the ash vs alder question and helps you choose the best wood for your own build.

Alder, ash and mahogany guitar bodies side by side, unfinished
Three of our unfinished bodies: alder, ash and mahogany.

How much does the wood change the sound?

On an acoustic guitar the wood is the sound. On a solid body electric the pickups, the strings and the setup do most of the work, and the body wood adds a smaller layer: a little more brightness, warmth or sustain. Players argue about how much you can really hear, but everybody agrees on what you can feel and see:

  • Weight: from about 3 kg for a light body to over 4.5 kg for a heavy one, once built.
  • Grain: open-grain woods like ash show a strong pattern under a clear finish; closed-grain woods like alder are smoother to paint.
  • Hardness: soft woods dent more easily and hold screws less well.

So pick the wood for weight and looks first, then let the tone be the bonus.

The best woods for an electric guitar, one by one

Alder

Medium weight, tight grain, balanced tone with clear mids. Alder has been the standard on ST-style guitars since the mid 1950s because it is light enough, stable and takes paint beautifully. The grain is plain, so most alder guitars get a solid color or a sunburst. Our alder Strat body starts from $146.

Unfinished alder ST-style body with routed cavities
Alder: plain, tight grain that paints well.

Ash and swamp ash

Ash has a bold, open grain and a bright, snappy tone with tight lows. It is the classic wood of the early TL-style guitars. Swamp ash comes from the lower trunk of ash trees growing in wet ground: it is noticeably lighter and is the one players look for. Northern or hard ash is heavier and brighter. Ash looks its best under a clear, translucent or ceruse finish. See our ash TL body (from $146) and the ash guitar body.

Unfinished ash TL-style body showing the open grain
Ash: the open grain shows through a clear finish.

Mahogany

Medium to heavy, warm, with strong mids and a long sustain. It is the wood of single-cut and double-cut set-neck guitars, often with a maple top. Mahogany has a fine, open pore and a reddish-brown color that darkens beautifully with a stain. Most of our kits use mahogany or ash. Try a mahogany guitar body, from $117.

Unfinished mahogany TL-style body
Mahogany: warm tone, reddish-brown wood.

Basswood

Light, soft and very even, with a smooth, slightly compressed tone that suits high-gain playing. It is easy to machine and paint, which is why it is common on budget and shred guitars. The downside: it dents easily.

Poplar

Light and cheap, with a plain grain and sometimes green or grey streaks. Tone close to alder. Almost always painted in a solid color.

Maple

Hard, heavy and bright. A full maple body is rare; maple is used as a top glued on mahogany to add bite and a figured look, and of course for necks.

Paulownia and okoume

Very light woods used on some entry-level and travel guitars. Comfortable, but soft and plain.

Walnut, korina and other exotic woods

Walnut is heavy and dark, korina (limba) light and warm, and woods like zebrawood or padauk are chosen mostly for their looks. Often used as a top or a veneer rather than a full body.

Body wood comparison table

Wood Weight Grain Tone Best finishes
Alder Medium Closed, plain Balanced, clear mids Solid colors, sunburst
Swamp ash Light to medium Open, bold Bright, airy Clear, translucent, ceruse
Northern ash Heavy Open, bold Bright, snappy Clear, translucent
Mahogany Medium to heavy Fine, open Warm, thick mids Stain, clear, solid colors
Basswood Light Very fine Smooth, even Solid colors
Poplar Light Plain Close to alder Solid colors
Maple Heavy Closed, can be figured Bright, tight Tops, clear, burst
Paulownia Very light Plain Soft, light Solid colors
Weight varies more inside one species than between species

Two alder bodies can differ by half a kilo. If weight matters to you, ask for the weight of the actual body.

Ash vs alder: which one for your build?

The classic question for TL-style and ST-style guitars. In short:

  • Choose ash if you want to see the grain under a clear or translucent finish, and you like a bright, cutting tone.
  • Choose alder if you plan a solid paint job, want a smoother, rounder tone and a lighter, more predictable weight than hard ash.

In a band mix, most people cannot hear the difference between the two once the pickups and amp are the same. The finish you want is usually the deciding factor.

How to choose the best body wood for your build

  • Clear or natural finish: ash, swamp ash or mahogany, or any body with a figured top.
  • Solid paint: alder, basswood or poplar. You will not see the grain, so do not pay for it.
  • Light guitar: swamp ash, basswood or a chambered body.
  • Warm, thick sound with humbuckers: mahogany, with or without a maple top.
  • Bright, clear single-coil sound: ash or alder.
  • Ready-made: every unfinished guitar body we make comes routed and ready to finish.
  • Making your own shape: start from a glued blank, such as our ash body blank (from $117), the mahogany body blank or the ST-style body blank. All our tonewood blanks are in one place.
Glued three-piece ash blank marked for an ST-style body
A glued ash blank, ready to cut to your own shape.

Wood and finish: plan them together

Open-grain woods (ash, mahogany) need a grain filler before a smooth gloss finish, or the pores show through as tiny pits. Our guide shows how to apply grain filler, and our natural grain filler works on both. On ash you can also do the opposite and fill the grain with a contrasting color: that is a ceruse finish.

Not sure how a color will look on a wood? Try it on an ash test piece first, from $18.

Figured tops and veneers

Flame, quilt and spalted figure come from maple and ash. A full figured body is expensive, so most guitars glue a thin top or a veneer onto a plainer body. A fleece-backed veneer such as our quilted maple veneer or flamed ash veneer gives you the look on any flat-top body at a fraction of the price.

Book-matched quilted maple veneer for a guitar top
Quilted maple veneer, book-matched for a guitar top.

FAQ

What is the best wood for an electric guitar?

There is no single best wood. Alder and ash are the classic choices for bolt-on guitars, mahogany for warm set-neck guitars. Choose by weight and by the finish you want.

Is ash or alder better?

Ash for a visible grain and a brighter tone, alder for solid paint, a rounder tone and a more even weight.

What is swamp ash?

Ash from the lower trunk of trees growing in wet ground. It is lighter than northern ash and prized for its airy tone.

Does body wood affect tone on an electric guitar?

A little. Pickups, strings and setup matter more, but the wood changes the weight, the sustain and the feel.

Which body wood is the lightest?

Paulownia, basswood and swamp ash are among the lightest. Weight also varies a lot from one piece to another.

Torna al blog

Lascia un commento

Si prega di notare che, prima di essere pubblicati, i commenti devono essere approvati.